Here is the long promised analysis of the shipping paperwork of Brian Moore, kill buyer and horse dealer from Jonestown, Pennsylvania. While the most recent information was requested, it is difficult to be sure of some of the shipping dates as Moore seems to submit paperwork that isn’t dated, by and large, and apparently the Canadian Food Inspection Agency is unbothered by that detail.
(you’ll need to download it and it’s a large file)
The sobering note is, that these 790 pages of paperwork document the slaughterhouse deaths of 7,140 equines.
Rest in peace.
Of those 7,100 plus horses, only 18 were documented as ponies.
38 were gray horses. That translates into 1% of the horses Moore ships.
153 were documented as drafts, which is 2% of his shipping numbers.
The number of Thoroughbreds he’s shipping is significant. He listed 800. That amounts to 11% of what he ships.
Most folks know Moore and other local kill buyers have their direct to kill pens – the horses that come off that backside and never get run through auctions. And Moore’s farm is in very close proximity to Penn National. Of course not all of those TBs came directly off the track, but considering Penn Gaming’s zero tolerance policy, makes you wonder how many did, doesn’t it?
A few other things of note. We’ve all heard dozens of times that once the horses are tagged and on the manifest, they cannot be pulled off. In this particular case there are numerous cases where a horse is listed, then a line is put through the listing and it says “not on the load.” Take a look at pages 476, 505, 546, 629, 638, 709, 713 – and there are others.
On page 534 they slipped in a page from Leroy Baker. Note he shipped a mustang, and four horses listed on his load didn’t get shipped.
Now it’s possible these horses were rejected at the border, but it certainly belies the assertion that they are absolutely gone once tagged, or written up – you know the mantra. We can’t be sure why those horses were removed from the load.
So repeat after me --- Brian Moore doesn’t ship ponies to slaughter, especially minis, week after week after week as the broker owned programs are telling you. And he rarely ships gray horses – one in one hundred. Very few drafts are shipped by him – two out of a hundred.
What he does like is the big, healthy, beefy quarter horses. And lots of horses listed in the “other” category, which is likely a lot of Standardbreds and Paints, breeds of good flesh and less bone. The horses you never see on the broker owned pages. Consigned to their deaths without a chance because they are healthy and will yield lots of good meat.
Lots of thoughts swirl through your head after looking over the documentation. But horse dealers are horse dealers, right? Some folks call them unwanted horses, but for these dealers they are very much wanted, and will make good use of them, dead or alive.